Saturday, January 30, 2010

Atkins wasn't just the Galileo of dieticians. We now know its the Thatcherite diet too.

A while ago, I wrote a short piece for the Conservative Home Piece about the Dr Atkins diet. The article was written after I had read an excellent book, called The Hungry Years by William Leith.

My argument was as follows:

"Reading an excellent book by journalist William Leith, The Hungry Years, a quirky and witty look at food and other addictions, I was reminded that almost exactly five years ago, ground-breaking proponent of a low-carb diet, Dr Robert Atkins, died after slipping on his way to work. Even his death attracted controversy, with his critics arguing that he collapsed because of heart failure and ended his life an obese man. None of this was true. William Leith interviewed Dr Atkins a few months before his death and found Dr Atkins to be healthy and of average build. Newsweek magazine, which had published some of the myths about his death, later published a retraction, acknowledging 'inaccuracies'.

William Leith notes that the Atkins low carb diet had a serious impact on the commercial food industry, particularly with his assault on refined carbohydrates (e.g. white bread etc) and so called low fat products - which in reality, are nothing of the kind. In response, a number of studies were published purporting to debunk Atkins, but many of which were found to be directly or indirectly funded by the commercial food lobby.

The Atkins diet first came out in the seventies and has had tipping points in the 80s, 90s and early 2000's. What has been interesting is that whenever there was a resurgence, because of scientific evidence, there was a furious backlash by the carbohydrate industry, worried at potential slippage in the enormous profits of addictive carb-type food. Brilliantly, the food industry has painted the Atkins diet at causing kidney failure, bad breath, not allowing any carbs or fibre, etc etc. None of which are true. So Dr Atkins has been cast as a heretic across the board, merely for challenging existing assumptions, daring to oppose the carb-food lobby, and confronting the cosy consensus on diets. But just like Galileo, the real truth about Dr Atkins will out itself eventually."


I have always been a passionate proponent and doer of the Atkins diet - and this is not just because I love, meat, egg and cheese. Atkins is a diet that works. Cutting the carbs does lead to significant weight loss. I know this from personal experience over the years.

So I was delighted to learn that Atkins is a Thatcherite diet too. According to the Margaret Thatcher papers released yesterday, the Iron Lady, was on the Atkins diet before the 1979 election. She was eating up to 28 eggs a week - albeit for a short period. As the Daily Telegraph notes today, the former Prime Minister was also munching through plenty of steak, spinach and salad, with the occasional glass of whisky! Well, no wonder she won the 1979 election. It makes sense - all that protein helped put the iron in the Iron Lady.

P.S. On reading the news, I had to have a huge mushroom and tomato omelette this afternoon (a late lunch) at the excellent Harlow Grill cafe in Little Walk, Harlow, although it wasn't quite twenty eight eggs. This omelette had come after many strenuous hours of campaigning of course....

by Robert Halfon - www.roberthalfon.blogspot.com

2 comments:

  1. Thank you Rob for this post I am a huge fan of Adkins because it works. Not only do I lose weight I do it without feeling hungry. I was on the maintenance stage when Dr Adkins died and reading all the negative press (a single mother of two) I became scared for my family and stopped it. I never until today found out the truth about Dr Adkins' death, thank you.

    I blogged on the topic on (www.walaaidris.com) but from a different more girly angle

    ReplyDelete
  2. in 1991, while she was still Prime Minister, Margaret Thatcher was kind enough to send me her favourite recipe (and a signed photograph) for a book I was producing to raise funds for a multiple sclerosis self help and physiotherapy group I'd co-founded.The group later became the Harlow branch of ARMS (Action and Research for Multiple Sclerosis) and part of the Harlow branch of the Multiple Sclerosis Society after ARMs went into liquidation.

    PM Thatcher responded so quickly and generously, and with such effusive praise for our efforts in founding the group, that it made me feel guilty for disliking her and her policies.

    The recipe Mrs Thatcher sent was for a very sharp lemon tart; loaded with carbs. Little wonder then that she needed to go on crash diets from time to time :o)

    ReplyDelete